« Republican Presidential Front Runner Websites Leave A Lot On The Table | Main | Women of Internet Marketing Wednesday Part 14 »

March 21, 2007

Does The NFL Not Understand the DMCA?

By Li Evans

Nfl_2 Chalk this one up to "I should have read the fine print all the way through."  Once and a while, I find something on Digg that piques my interest and this morning it seems, the NFL just doesn't understand how to use the DMCA properly when sending out take down notices.  Apparently it also doesn't understand the full and broad reaching meaning of "fair use."  Enter law professor Wendy Seltzer.

Wendy, who started the Chilling Effects Clearinghouse website, was also a lawyer for the Electronic Frontier Foundation at one point in time.  Ms. Seltzer decided what better way to demonstrate to her class that the copyright statement the NFL airs before the Superbowl (and for any other football game for that matter) does not make exception for common fair use, than to demonstrate it on YouTube.

Superbowllogo "This telecast is copyrighted by the NFL for the private use of our audience, and any other use of this telecast or of any pictures, descriptions or accounts of the game without the NFL's consent is prohibited"

Her demonstration included putting a clip up on YouTube which did include the copyright notice (stated above).  Within a few days, YouTube sent her a copy of the NFL's DMCA order, which YouTube abides by (see Viacom, they do take things down).  The story doesn't end there though, Seltzer, a very well versed lawyer in DMCA law, sent a counter-notification using the "fair use" clause of the DMCA.  Again, YouTube abides the DMCA and replaces it.

Wendyseltzer_2 Here's where things get interesting.  For all the "legal-eze" Ms. Seltzer has an explanation on her blog, but in a nutshell, since the NFL sent yet another DMCA request, they are now in violation of the DMCA.  Why?  Seltzer explains that because the NFL did not acknowledge the clip as fair use and sent another take down notice, they are now in violation of  the DMCA section 512(f)(1).  That section of the law states that sending another take-down notice over the same content is considered a knowing misrepresentation that the clip is infringing.  Yes, confusing for us non-lawyer types.  Maybe Kevin O'Keefe (my favorite blogging lawyer) over at LexBlog could chime in?

So what's next?  That I'm not sure of, but I'm going to keep an eye on Wendy's blog and keep you appraised of the situation.  This should prove very interesting, and I bet Viacom is going to be watching this closely, too, since Google/YouTube stance on the Viacom suit is "fair use."

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341bfb1a53ef00d83525832b69e2

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Does The NFL Not Understand the DMCA?:

Comments

I may be your favorite blogging lawyer but I should probably keep my head down when you have legal experts on copyright law and in particular the DMCA involved. Does sound like the NFL may have overreacted to example where one uses copyrighted materials as part of a teaching effort.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Get SMG Today - Free!

Get SMG by RSS What Is RSS?
Get Search Marketing Gurus Today via RSS! Add to Google Reader or Homepage
Add to netvibes
Get SMG in Your Bloglines
Get SMG in Your NewsGator Online

Get SMG by E-Mail
Subscribe to SMG via Email
Enter your email address:


Delivered by FeedBurner

SMG Conversations

If You Like SMG Favorite Us on Technorati!
Add to Technorati Favorites
If You Like What SMG Has To Say, Joins Us At These Places!
Subscribe on YouTube to SMG's Videos
follow Li on Twitter
Follow Li on FriendFeed




Copyright 2006, 2007, 2008 SearchMarketingGurus.com