« Donald Trump's Websites - When Big Names Get Online Marketing All Wrong | Main | When Creative Commons Licensing Gets Taken For Granted »

February 10, 2007

Could Wikipedia Actually Close in the Next 3-4 Months? Let's Take A Closer Look.

By Li Evans

Florencedevouard There's some articles out in the blogosphere right now quoting a speech given by Florence Devouard at the Lift '07 Conference in Geneva last week.  Florence Devouard is the chairwoman of the Wikimedia Foundation which runs the non-profit Wikipedia.  What has sparked a lot of buzz is what she said about Wikimedia's funding, that basically, one could summarize that Wikimedia is in pretty dire straights.

At this point, Wikipedia has the financial resources to run its servers for about 3 to 4 months. If we do not find additional funding, it is not impossible that Wikipedia might disappear”.

Now that stated, Wikimedia's had to do some back pedaling on what was actually stated in the speech.  Sandra Ordonez, Wikimedia's communications director has been doing "cleanup" and posting on blogs that have the piece from Devouard's speech with the following:


So, with that stated, I opted to do a little digging, especially in light of the news that they just raised over a million dollars (US) in the past few weeks.  Also, although not directly relevant is the fact that Wikia,Inc.,  the for profit "sister" of Wikimedia, just raised $4 million in capital from Bessemer Venture Partners last year.  I just kept wondering, how in the world could Wikimedia be in that dire of straights?

The issue at the root of the cash crunch at Wikimedia Foundation, is its growing popularity.  Its growing popularity means, the need for more hardware (servers, etc.) and higher hosting fees for the network sites, since Wikipedia is now in several languages.  Last year alone the Wikimedia Foundation had to shell out close to $190,000 in hosting fees.  I thought perhaps that this could be one of those foundations that pay their directors exorbitantly, but not the case here at all, salaries  and wages were just over $107,000.  So if they have a tech person or two, plus their director and their communications director, that $107,000 is a pretty decent amount for their staff.

Wikimediafoundationbenefactors I then went from their financial statements to look at who their publicized benefactors were, from which in 2006 they received just over $1.3 million in contributions.  There's not too many "big" names on there.  Yahoo! does contribute with help with their servers in China, Dell with discounted equipment, and Answers.com created their "1 Click Answers - Wikipedia Edition" software.

But then I saw one company, in particular that jumped out at me, on the $1,000 to $4999.99 category - Wikia, Inc.  So I guess Wikimedia Foundation expects the general public to believe they are in these dire straights, without absolutely no one to help, so that the general public will just open their wallets and donate. 

Wikialogo Me, I'm a bit more skeptical and less believing of speeches and hype.  Do you really believe that Wikia, Inc. would let Wikipedia - it's flagship "sister" site - close?  I don't doubt the the venture funding folks took a look at Wikipedia and that was one of their major reasons for investing that $4 million in Wikia, Inc.  If Wikipedia closed, just how would that look for Wikia, Inc. and their chances for future funding? 


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Could Wikipedia Actually Close in the Next 3-4 Months? Let's Take A Closer Look.:

» Death of Wikipedia? Funding woes? from WebMetricsGuru
Now that Im subscribed to GrokDotComs RSS feed - Im picking up all kind of stuff, some of it I already know about and some I didnt like Wikipedias funding woes from Search Marketing Gurus, I blog I never heard... [Read More]

» The Wikimedia cash crunch story: what Devouard really said from Lunch over IP
Florence Devouard, chairwoman of the Wikimedia Foundation - which owns the online encyclopedia Wikipedia - on Thursday at LIFT07 in Geneva said that they currently have cash to pay the bills for about three months (see my original post - [Read More]


Thanks Li for mentioning my post from LIFT, but let me point you to another one where I relate a discussion I had with Devouard, because she never said that Wikipedia would shut down: she just said that they had 3/4 months of cash in the bank, but she repeatedly told me that the had "no worry for the future" of Wikipedia:
The idea that Wikipedia could "shut down in 3/4 months" is a morph of her original statement by bloggers that were not at LIFT. Have a happy day, B.

Um, Wikia is not a "for-profit sister" of Wikipedia/Wikimedia. It's a completely separate organisation - your phrasing implies it's a for-profit subsidiary, like Mozilla Corporation/Mozilla Foundation. This is not the case, even though the press keep getting this wrong. (We figure another six to twelve months of corrections every time from both Wikimedia and Wikia may alleviate this.)

Bruno - basically what I was trying to point out, was that the possibility that it would shut down it pretty absurd. Wikia, Inc. wouldn't let that happen.

David - In reality it is "a-kin" to Wikia. It uses its platform and Mr. Wells has interlinked the two together on more than one occasion. Plus, as I've stated, who REALLY believes that Wikipedia would just shut down, there's no way that'd ever happen because of it's "kinship" to Wikia. Wikimedia is Not-For-Profit ... Wikia is for profit .... Just like I'm my parent's daughter, and I'm a red head, and my sister is a brunette. We're both rooted from the same place - we're still related just different.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Get SMG Today - Free!

Get SMG by RSS What Is RSS?
Get Search Marketing Gurus Today via RSS! Add to Google Reader or Homepage
Add to netvibes
Get SMG in Your Bloglines
Get SMG in Your NewsGator Online

Get SMG by E-Mail
Subscribe to SMG via Email
Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

SMG Conversations

If You Like SMG Favorite Us on Technorati!
Add to Technorati Favorites
If You Like What SMG Has To Say, Joins Us At These Places!
Subscribe on YouTube to SMG's Videos
follow Li on Twitter
Follow Li on FriendFeed

Copyright 2006, 2007, 2008 SearchMarketingGurus.com